top of page
Nov 2
5 min read

Is SMS Marketing Profitable? How to Calculate ROI After Costs and Discounts

By Trayan Hristov · Thrivelia · Published 2 November 2026

A commercial readout starts with net retained sales and subtracts product, fulfilment, messaging and other defined costs to assess contribution.

SMS marketing is profitable when the additional contribution it creates exceeds the cost of running it. To answer that question, start with the bill, the economics of the orders and a clear definition of what would have happened without the messages.

A dashboard can show a strong revenue multiple while leaving that decision unresolved. I want to know which customers changed their behaviour, what those orders contributed and whether the next pound or dollar deserves the same allocation.

This guide gives you three calculations, a worked example and a way to decide what to test next. All example amounts are hypothetical US dollars. They are not client results or current platform rates.

Download the editable lifecycle workbook (XLSX) and open the SMS ROI tab. Replace the example inputs with your own evidence and record the decisions your team needs to make.

Start by naming the decision

Reviewing the whole SMS programme and deciding whether to send one additional campaign require different cost views. Write the decision at the top of the worksheet: keep the programme, change the plan, reduce frequency, narrow an audience or add a particular message.

For a programme review, include the relevant messaging bill, production, management and other programme costs. For an extra send, identify the costs that actually change. An existing retainer might stay the same, while a longer message or a higher plan tier changes expenditure.

Use one currency, reporting period and order definition throughout. Record the promotions, stock changes and other campaigns that could affect the comparison.

Keep these three views separate

View

Calculation

Decision it supports

Attributed revenue multiple

Revenue credited to SMS divided by the stated programme or message cost

Describe reported channel performance with a visible denominator

Order contribution

Net retained order revenue minus relevant variable order costs

Understand the economics of the purchases being assessed

Estimated incremental profit

Additional contribution versus a valid comparison, minus additional programme costs

Assess whether the intervention earned more than it cost

Klaviyo's message attribution documentation explains how eligible touchpoints and account settings assign conversion credit. Its conversion tracking guide also explains that an SMS delivery can qualify when delivery attribution is enabled. That credit does not establish that the customer read the text or bought because of it.

Record those settings before comparing months. Within a platform, channel credit can move between eligible touchpoints. Across separate reporting tools, the same purchase may be claimed more than once. Reconcile order IDs and definitions before adding channel totals. Our email attribution guide explains the broader measurement problem.

Calculate message usage, then reconcile the actual bill

For an SMS send, calculate each market's recipients multiplied by message segments and the applicable rate. Then sum the markets. Klaviyo's mobile messaging reference documents per-segment charging, country differences and the use of account-specific rates. Accounts still using credits should use their own credit schedule.

A fictional isolated send illustrates the method:

Market

Recipients

Segments

Assumed segment rate

Estimated usage cost

A

12,000

2

$0.01

$240

B

8,000

2

$0.04

$640

Total

20,000



$880

These invented rates are only arithmetic inputs. Replace them with the rates in your account. Message length, personalised content and character encoding can change the segment count, so inspect the actual send configuration.

Estimated usage and the bill can differ because of plan capacity and other billable activity. Keep both visible. Do not add a usage estimate to a subscription charge that already includes that usage. For a cost-saving decision, check whether removing a send would reduce the bill now, allow a future downgrade or only leave capacity unused.

Work out what a retained order contributes

Start with sales after discounts and refunds, excluding tax collected for authorities. Deduct the variable costs you include consistently: product cost, payment fees, fulfilment, shipping subsidy and return handling. Account for recoverable returned inventory consistently with your finance reporting.

If your revenue export is already net of discounts or refunds, do not deduct them again. If an offer includes a free item, include its product and fulfilment cost. A higher average order value can still leave less contribution when the incentive is expensive.

Keep messaging and programme costs outside this order calculation if you subtract them afterwards. The result is a decision-specific contribution measure. It does not represent company-wide accounting profit after every overhead.

A 12-times revenue multiple can still leave the programme at break-even

Consider a hypothetical test period. The SMS expense is $1,000 and the work required to run the programme costs another $400. Klaviyo credits $12,000 of revenue to SMS.

The reported revenue divided by message expense is 12 times. Using the full $1,400 programme cost gives an attributed revenue multiple of approximately 8.6 times. Neither calculation accounts for order margins or the purchases that would have happened anyway.

Now suppose eligible customers were randomly assigned to equally sized groups. The treatment receives the promotional SMS policy under review. The control does not. Other communication and commercial conditions remain comparable.

Same observation period

SMS treatment

Control

Assigned customers

20,000

20,000

Retained orders

600

560

Net retained order revenue

$60,000

$56,000

Variable order costs

$39,000

$36,400

Order contribution

$21,000

$19,600

Contribution per assigned customer

$1.05

$0.98

The observed contribution difference is $0.07 per customer. Applied to the 20,000 treatment customers, that is $1,400. Subtracting the $1,400 programme cost leaves an estimated incremental result of $0.

The comparison includes all eligible store orders in each group, not only orders credited to SMS. In this simplified example, each additional retained order contributes $35, so covering $1,400 requires 40 additional orders. The observed order difference is exactly 40.

These counts provide a point estimate, not a statistical verdict. A real experiment needs an uncertainty assessment and checks for group contamination. The example shows why the financial conclusion cannot come from the 12-times dashboard figure alone.

Make the comparison answer the right question

For the value of SMS alongside email, keep the ordinary email policy comparable and vary the SMS policy. For the value of a combined email-and-SMS programme, test that complete policy and describe the broader question.

Assign eligible people before treatment. Keep them in their assigned groups for the agreed period. Compare outcomes per assigned customer, including people who did not receive a message or purchase. Comparing SMS subscribers with unrelated non-subscribers does not create an equivalent control.

Choose a period that allows purchases and returns to emerge. Plan the sample, primary outcome and analysis before sending. A small or inconclusive result can justify further learning; it should not become a confident claim of either success or failure.

Decide what to change

Finding

Useful next decision

Spend rises because messages use more segments

Review length and content while preserving the essential offer and opt-out information

One market has weak contribution after its actual messaging cost

Test that market's audience, timing and offer separately

Attributed revenue rises but combined customer contribution does not

Investigate channel overlap and offer cost before increasing frequency

A relevant message has credible positive incremental economics

Expand carefully and check whether the economics hold as the audience changes

I would review campaign SMS separately from triggered messages, then examine the customer decision each message serves. A requested restock alert and a repeated general promotion deserve different hypotheses.

Use the worksheet to record what you know, what remains an assumption and which decision the next test must resolve. If the missing work is diagnosis, measurement or coordinated execution, our service options explain the available scopes.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good SMS marketing ROI?

There is no useful universal target without a cost and margin definition. Set the required return against your alternative uses of money, uncertainty and business constraints. Keep the attributed revenue multiple separate from incremental profit.

Should we stop SMS if a test is inconclusive?

Assess the cost of continuing, the size of the remaining uncertainty and the value of further evidence. A narrower audience or simpler test may be a better next step than applying one unclear result to every message.

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page