Supplement Reorder SMS Timing and Copy for Klaviyo
By Trayan Hristov · Founder, Thrivelia · 19 November 2026
I’d send a supplement reorder text when the customer still has enough product to wait for delivery. For some brands that might be day 24. For someone who bought two bottles, day 24 might be six weeks too early. Both people can look exactly the same in a flow triggered by “placed order”.
Here’s how I’d set up the first version for a brand selling one-time purchases through Shopify and Klaviyo.
What day should the reorder text arrive?
Start with one product and one pack size. Pull the first delivery date and the next order date for people who bought that product again. Separate one-time sales from subscriptions and single packs from bundles. Count the customers who haven’t bought again as well. The time between repeat orders tells you when repeat buyers acted. It doesn’t tell you everyone else has run out.
Take a fictional bottle with 30 days of supply according to its label. Suppose a refill usually takes four days to arrive and you want two days of breathing room. Day 24 after delivery is a sensible first test. That leaves four days in transit and two in reserve. The same maths puts a two-bottle order around day 54 if one person uses them in sequence. If buyers often share the bundle, that assumption is worth testing. Use the actual pack instructions and delivery experience for your own product.
If you only have order dates, check a sample of fulfilment and delivery times before setting the delay. A Friday order that arrives the following Wednesday has already used five days on the reporting clock. Klaviyo’s replenishment flow guide.
What should the text say?
For a one-time purchase, I’d start with something the customer can answer for themselves. Two example messages follow. Replace the sample brand and links with your approved sender identity, product link and required opt-out wording.
“Field Goods: Running low on your 30-pack? Here’s the same one you ordered last time: [refill link]. Reply STOP to opt out.”
If a refill page lets the customer choose size, a second version is worth testing. “Field Goods: Ready for another pack? Choose your usual size or a different one here: [product link]. Reply STOP to opt out.”
The first message removes a choice. The second makes a choice easy. Neither needs a discount to be useful. Don’t say “you’re out tomorrow” unless you actually know that. A customer who only opened the bottle last week will notice.
Who should receive it in Klaviyo?
Start with an order event that contains the relevant product. Check the event on a real test profile before building your filter. Use the purchased item and quantity to route people into the correct timing. If your integration only makes order-level data available, launch with a single unambiguous SKU while you check how bundles come through.
Immediately before the SMS, check that marketing SMS consent is active, that the customer hasn’t already reordered the product and that the SKU can still be bought. Exclude refunds and cancellations where the data is reliable. An unrelated order can be a perfectly good reason to keep the original refill reminder. A replacement bottle is a good reason to stop it.
Active subscribers with an upcoming shipment need their subscription experience. Suppress them from the one-time refill text. If your subscription platform already sends a renewal reminder, check a subscriber’s timeline in both systems. With delayed or missing subscription events, start with customers whose one-time status you can verify. Klaviyo’s instructions for SMS in replenishment flows.
How do you know the text earned a second order?
Give eligible customers the same email sequence. Randomly assign some to receive the additional text and leave the rest on email alone. Choose a reorder window before launch that is long enough to see the next natural purchase. Count all qualifying store orders per assigned customer, whether or not they clicked the text. Track messaging cost, contribution after discounts, opt-outs and the time to purchase.
Suppose 1,000 customers get the extra SMS and 1,000 stay on email alone. If 90 reorder in the first group and 80 in the second, that’s a one percentage point difference. At £18 contribution per reorder, the observed difference is £180 before the extra messaging cost. It’s also only ten orders. Check uncertainty and allow time to see whether the text simply brought orders forward.
With Sunday Scaries, our published reporting excluded automatic subscription rebills from the comparison. We use the same distinction here because a scheduled renewal can make a refill flow look productive even when nobody placed a new order. That case describes the account’s email work. The SMS examples and numbers above are illustrative. Read the Sunday Scaries measurement notes.
Before switching it on, test a single-pack buyer, a bundle buyer, someone who already reordered and an active subscriber. Record who received the text and where its link landed. If the last two get the message, fix eligibility first. See the full Klaviyo replenishment flow.

.png)



Comments