top of page
2d
3 min read

Are missing sizes costing us repeat purchases?

By Trayan Hristov · Founder, Thrivelia · 19 November 2026

A style can be “in stock” while the size your returning shopper wants has been gone for three weeks. Before changing the winback offer, I’d ask the buyer for the stock history of the sizes your customers actually tried to buy.

Count genuine attempts

Record the style, colour, selected size, timestamp and inventory state at the moment of selection. Count one shopper trying a given variant once per session. A customer tapping a disabled size repeatedly is one frustrated person. Keep product-page views without a size selection separate. A past purchase can suggest fit, but people buy gifts, change sizes and shop for others.

If sizes vanish from the selector when they sell out, you have missing intent data. Start with explicit notify-me requests, support enquiries and unavailable selectors where they exist. These are lower-bound signals, and customers willing to join a waitlist differ from everyone else.

Build an availability measure around returning shoppers

In a fictional week, returning shoppers made 500 distinct size-selection attempts. On 140 occasions the selected variant was unavailable. Your demand-weighted availability was 360 divided by 500, or 72%. The catalogue could still show nearly every style as available. Calculate the number by style family and size, then compare returning and first-time shoppers so a paid-media surge doesn’t hide the difference.

Look ahead seven days. Of the 140 blocked attempts, how many people bought another colour or size, visited a store, or bought after a restock? Never convert every blocked attempt into a “lost sale”. If comparable in-stock sessions convert at 20%, 28 orders is a scenario before substitution. Differences in stock, time and audience limit its interpretation.

Test a buying change as well as a message

Pick a core style with repeat demand and a reasonably stable lead time. Rebalance the next small buy towards the constrained sizes, keeping the overall units and campaign plan visible. Compare availability, sell-through at full price, cancelled orders and contribution after returns. With little traffic, use matched style families and read results directionally.

For an alert, recheck the specific size at send and landing. Pause the campaign if stock is too shallow. For a buying meeting, bring the three variants with the most blocked attempts and the stock required to cover the observed demand. That gives merchandising and CRM a shared decision. Footwear fit and lifecycle example · Back-in-stock execution for fashion.

Put a value on the next size buy

If 100 comparable blocked sessions are observed for size M and you model 15 purchases had the size been available, allow for substitutions. Suppose six customers later bought the same style in another colour at the same margin. The remaining nine orders at £25 contribution give a £225 opportunity scenario before extra inventory and markdown risk. If the supplier’s minimum buy exposes you to £600 of likely leftover stock, a waitlist or smaller replenishment may be the better move. Treat the conversion assumption as the part to test. Shopify’s inventory report definitions.

Ask ChatGPT or Claude about your own numbers

Here are size-selection attempts, availability at selection, later substitutions and returns by variant. Which size curves are constraining returning customers? Give a range for possible lost orders and show the assumptions behind it.

Related reading

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page