Updated: 8 hours ago
3 Email and SMS Agencies for Supplement and Wellness Brands
Ask a supplement agency to open last month’s revenue report and take out the orders that renewed automatically. Then ask what changed. I’d learn more from that conversation than from the size of the number on the first slide.
Start with the ordering model. A customer buying a single bottle has a decision to make next month. A subscriber may be charged automatically, skip a shipment or cancel because product is piling up. Choose a case that covers the same decision and ask who owned the change.
Thrivelia for the route from a one-off order to a reorder
At Sunday Scaries, reported email revenue was 39.8% higher in July 2024 than in June. The comparison excluded automatic subscription rebills. Our work included campaign strategy, welcome offers, recovery and post-purchase journeys. It was a month-on-month comparison across the account, so I wouldn’t use that number to tell you what one email earned. Read the Sunday Scaries case and its measurement notes.
For your account, I’d start with the product most new customers buy. Of the people who bought it once, how many placed another order themselves? How many took a subscription instead? How many had a payment run because they were already subscribed? Once you can answer those separately, you can give the team a sensible job. The first group may need a well-timed refill reminder. An existing subscriber may need to change the date of their next delivery.
YOCTO for a Klaviyo programme that needs rebuilding
YOCTO’s Vital Nutritive case describes a situation a lot of operators will recognise. Campaigns leaned heavily on promotions. The follow-up after purchase was thin. Several flows overlapped. YOCTO describes remapping those journeys, rebuilding onboarding and retargeting, and checking that the signup promise carried into the welcome series. Read YOCTO’s Vital Nutritive case.
If that sounds like your account, ask for one customer’s message history across a launch week. I’d want to see what happens when the same person qualifies for a checkout reminder, a scheduled campaign and a subscription email. Which one wins, who changes that priority, and can someone in your team see the rule after handover?
Andzen for a migration across different product lines
Rose-Hip Vital sells supplements for dogs, horses and people. A long-standing customer buying from the human range for the first time is new to that category and familiar with the brand. Treating that order as the person’s first ever purchase would repeat the wrong introduction. Andzen describes building category-aware triggers as part of the brand’s Klaviyo migration. Read Andzen’s Rose-Hip Vital case.
I’d put that capability high on the list if you sell across a family of products or storefronts. Give the agency a test profile with two years of purchase history in one range and a single purchase in another. Ask them to show which welcome, education and reorder messages it would receive after migration. A proposal that names the fields it needs to preserve is easier to evaluate than a promise to personalise everything.
Give each agency the same three orders
Start with a customer who bought one pack, someone who bought a three-pack on the same date, and an active subscriber with a shipment due next week. Give the agency your actual fulfilment times and the pack instructions. Ask for the first email, the first SMS and the reason to suppress either one. See our worked supplement reorder SMS example.
Then ask which outcome would earn the next month of budget. For example, from 500 first-time one-off buyers with a full 90 days of observation, 70 place a voluntary second order. That cohort’s 90-day second-order rate is 14%. A further 40 automatic rebills elsewhere in the business belong on a separate line. Count customers once, distinguish cancellations and refunds, and make sure every cohort has had the same time to return.
Finally, give the proposed writer one approved product statement and its source. Ask for a subject line, a text message and a plain-English limit on what the copy can claim. You’ll see how the team handles a real constraint before your brand’s name is on the send.
Speak to the person who would manage the account. Ask them to walk through a missed refill, a pause and a cancellation, including who checks the product copy, who changes the billing journey and what gets counted as a genuine reorder.

.png)



Comments