PupMD: Subscription Email Marketing Case Study

LIFECYCLE CASE STUDY

From checkout to the next scoop.

PupMD’s implementation connected welcome, checkout, payment and post-purchase messages to the events behind a subscription business.

Implementation and research: July–September 2026

LIFECYCLE CASE STUDY

Three decisions behind the work.

Implementation and research: July–September 2026

01 · THE CONTEXT

One customer. Several very different moments.

PupMD’s customer journey continued well beyond the first order. The implementation had to connect Klaviyo messages with checkout and subscription activity, while giving owners a useful next step after buying. A paid order, a failed payment, a paused subscription and a cancellation each called for a different response.

There was also a messaging challenge. In August 2026, Thrivelia reviewed the emerging picture from the brand’s quiz responses. The audience was more specific than “dog owners worried about itching”. Many described a longer history of trying solutions, experiencing temporary changes and still feeling uncertain about what to do next.

That insight gave the communication a clearer direction: acknowledge the owner’s experience, explain the next step and make it easy to take. It was a customer-understanding exercise, not evidence of a medical outcome or a measured increase in conversion.

THE STRATEGY BEHIND THE BUILD

Design the follow-up around the dog, not just the order date.

The April 2026 strategy began with a practical question: what has to happen after acquisition for a pet owner to stay? The proposed programme connected quiz answers, customer personas, product education and replenishment timing, so the first purchase could become the start of an ongoing relationship.

One important planning distinction was consumption. A customer buying several boxes should not automatically receive the same replenishment prompt as someone buying one. Dog size could also affect how quickly a product was used. The proposal therefore called for timing based on expected supply, rather than a blanket monthly reminder. These were design principles in the strategy, not measured retention improvements.

Early customer education was another priority. The plan included a day-five check-in to explain product use and address common questions. The aim was to support the owner before uncertainty turned into disengagement. Any product-health guidance would need the brand’s expert approval; no medical or refund-reduction result is claimed here.

The proposal also considered two acquisition paths: a subscription-led first purchase, and a one-time purchase followed by a subscription invitation. Both needed a coherent lifecycle, but the offer framing and follow-up should reflect what the customer had actually chosen. The later implementation work on purchase events, subscription states and destination links addressed that underlying need.

This is how the strategy and delivery fit together: the April plan defined the customer decisions the programme needed to support; the July–September work connected specific journeys to the events, eligibility rules and links that made them usable. The proposal’s financial scenarios were planning illustrations and are not presented as achieved results.

02 · THE WORK

The decisions behind the journey.

Connect the transaction events

The September work covered checkout SMS, failed-payment messages and post-purchase journeys. Subscription cancellation and pause messages included portal links.

Launch with exclusions

The welcome flow and pop-up were confirmed live, with exclusions added. Purchase and subscription state were important checks before a follow-up could be useful.

Separate active journeys from the backlog

The weekly report for 14–20 September recorded activity in SamCart post-purchase, replenishment and checkout flows. Refund, VIP, cross-sell and winback work still had outstanding steps in the surrounding updates.

CUSTOMER UNDERSTANDING

Use the quiz to listen before you personalise.

The quiz was more than another place to collect an email address. Its answers helped Thrivelia examine what owners had already tried and the frustrations they brought into the purchase decision. The resulting August analysis centred the messaging on recognition, explanation and renewed confidence in the next step.

The practical lesson is to use research to change the substance of an email. Knowing a customer’s name does little if the message ignores the experience that brought them to the brand. Here, the research pointed towards acknowledging repeated attempts and uncertainty before moving into product education.

Quiz and product-page destinations were also part of the post-purchase link updates confirmed in September. Research, email copy and the destination after the click needed to form one coherent experience.

IMPLEMENTATION DETAILS

The destination is part of the email.

Subscription state changes the next action

A cancellation or pause message needed to take the customer to the subscription portal. A post-purchase message could lead to the quiz or product information. The September delivery update confirmed these different destinations rather than routing every journey to the same storefront.

Check eligibility as well as the trigger

Testing exposed an important distinction: an event occurring did not necessarily make a profile eligible for SMS. The team checked subscription status and whether the relevant contact details had reached Klaviyo. The operational lesson is to test the complete path from capture to receipt.

Separate creative approval from activation

July updates tracked quiz embedding, portal links, offers and dynamic properties alongside the email builds. Some flows were live while other dependencies still needed confirmation. A completed design and a functioning customer journey are separate delivery milestones.

THE REPORTING DECISION

Agree what a conversion means before scaling.

The 18 August review surfaced an important reporting problem: the team needed to clarify how order and product events in Klaviyo mapped to actual payments. A later weekly update used a successfully-paid Stripe metric. Those reports should not be stitched into a growth comparison without first reconciling their event definitions and attribution settings.

The team also replaced ID-only tracking with readable UTM names for the channel, flow or campaign, message and send date. That made individual journeys easier to inspect. Payment reconciliation and the potential overlap between message types remained separate questions to resolve.

For another subscription brand, the practical sequence is to identify the payment event, compare it with the payment provider, then choose the reporting window and attribution rules. Only after those checks does a revenue total become a reliable basis for deciding which customer journey deserves more investment.

03 · THE OUTCOME

What the work delivered.

The September records show messages running through the implemented journeys. Revenue tracking used different payment and conversion definitions in the source material, so this page makes an implementation claim rather than a financial growth claim.

WHAT TO APPLY

Take the lesson into your own programme.

Define each event in plain language before building around it. A successful payment, a subscription update and an order are not interchangeable. Test the customer’s destination link as carefully as the message itself.

Implementation and research: July–September 2026. This case study covers the specific work described. Journey diagrams explain the approach.

QUESTIONS ABOUT THE WORK

What this case study shows.

How should subscription emails use quiz answers and payment events?

PupMD’s July–September 2026 implementation and research connected customer context with checkout, payment and post-purchase messages. Paid orders, failed payments, pauses and cancellations called for different responses and destination links. Quiz research informed messaging, while proposed consumption-based replenishment remained a strategy principle. The case documents implementation, not proven financial or medical outcomes.

How is subscription retention different from repeat-purchase marketing?

Subscription communication needs to recognise renewal, payment failure, pause, cancellation and product-use context. A one-time buyer may need an invitation to subscribe, while an existing subscriber needs support for the commitment already made. Evaluate these journeys against subscription outcomes rather than treating every attributed recurring order as a newly created sale.

YOUR NEXT CHAPTER

What could your email programme do next?

Find the opportunities in your customer journey.

Browse all Thrivelia case studies

Discuss your customer journey with Thrivelia